...they capture your memories and hold them ransom.
*Disclaimer - this is what it looks like when something really irritates me and I decide to do what I can about it...you've been warned.*
As promised yesterday I am here today to tell you my take on photo piracy. I'm not talking about taking photos off the internet and claiming them to be yours or distrubting them without permission from the artist - that is wrong, should be and is punishable by the law. My view of photo piracy is much more insidious. Let me give you some background. I recently discovered that a friend of mine had her wedding photographed by a professional photographer. I thought that was an excellent choice as it's an unforgettable event that deserves the expense of being properly recorded on film (SD card...). She paid for the photographer's time as well as the prints she ordered. In return for her investment she was not even given a proof set of prints to look through for ordering purposes. She had to select the prints she wanted from an online photo gallery (that was closed a few weeks after the wedding) not even having the luxury of viewing photos side by side to determine which was the one with the facial expression or hair she really wanted. When she asked if there was anyway to purchase a disk of the prints she was told something to the effect that maybe but all photos would be reduced to an image quality only good enough to print a four by six photo. Even still after various family members have tried there has been no response as to what the disk would cost or how to get it. What makes this so frustrating is that this newlywed couple who are just starting out together have already paid a substantial amount of money for essentially 6-10, albeit lovely, photos. The whole deal about withholding the digital copy of the photos wouldn't frustrate me half so much if they had at least been given a proof set. There are countless special shots that it's hard to justify spending $5-25 on because honestly for that much you can't put them in a coffee table photo book and really how many photos are you able to frame and put on your walls of one event?
As I was indulging in an incensed rant to Mycal on the matter - wondering why so many photographers feel justified in continuing to treat their clients in such an unbelievable manner I came across the perfect term for such practices - photographic piracy. They capture something of immense value to you then hold it ransom for unbelievable prices and conditions. Don't get me wrong I believe that people have a right to make money at their profession - especially if they are good at it. They are providing a valuable service that is worth being paid for. I just wonder at the need to withhold so much from a customer after they have given so much money. Here are some numbers based on one photographer I called after Liberty was born. She was a friend of the family but was giving me numbers based on the industry in the area. The sitting fee was $200 but $100 would go towards the print order. If you spent $200 on your print order ($300 total) you could purchase the disk of photos for an additional $100 making your total purchase around $400. I know and respect that photographers have to put a lot of money into their equipment and perhaps paying off school or taking classes, and like I said - if you are good you deserve to make a living at what you do. But I also believe there is a point when you go from making a living to abusing the consumer. My friend spent over seven hundred dollars on her wedding photos and still is unable to get a disk - even one with limited resolution. Her family have no photos of the day and will have to pay the photographers print price to get any. I wanted to make her a scrapbook as a wedding gift but at $5 dollars each 10 4x6 photos would cost $50 plus all the scrapbooking supplies. Now that it is evident that they can not pay any more the photographer is ignoring requests for a photo disk even though her website says you can add a copyrighted cd (I'm assuming for an additional cost though it won't say what.) Even more galling was to visit said website and see photos of this lovely couple being used as advertising for the photographers work - photos they can't afford to own.
Forgive my frustration on the matter - it still irritates me to no end. Like I said I understand that a person has to make a living however the wedding photographers work (she's doesn't exclusively do weddings...) isn't any better than the photographer who I talked to about doing Liberty. Her wedding prices may be higher but she is operating in the same area and I'd be very surprised if her general business practices where hugely different than what she outlined to me.
So here is what I am going to do about it - first encourage consumer awareness. I think that as consumers we need to make sure people know they work for us. We deserve to be treated with respect and the best way to get that is to let professionals know that we are proactively looking for what is best for us. I will talk to everybody I can about their photographic decisions and encourage questioning the photographer on such matters as cost, ability to get a disk copyrighted or otherwise, no matter how well you know the person. Second I am becoming a better photographer and sharing the pictures of others I take with them. I had a chance to take photos for my sister-in-law's wedding and believe me I felt the responsibility. I wish I had had more experience and better equipment. I am now more committed than ever to lugging my camera around with me and taking pictures of people with pride rather than being embarrassed about it so the next time somebody asks me I will be better prepared and able to do a better job. I will continue to study photography and improve my skills. I am happy to report that I started yesterday by photographing the birthday party we went too...while I don't think there were many spectacular shots I did catch a couple really fun ones especially one of the birthday boy blowing out his candles. I hope it's a shot that at some point is important to his parents (I heard them trying to get their camera ready but their hands were pretty full of other children.) I don't know if I will ever be a professional photographer. I will continue to improve my skills though and hopefully encourage more people to find those photographers who won't hold their memories ransom.
4 comments:
Ha! Beat Suzan!! (hmm...you don't think this will become a competition or anything do you? :) )
Anyway, I totally and completely agree with you Steph! That is just so sick and wrong that people would abuse consumers that way because when prices get that high that is just what it is- abuse.
We need to do something, and I'm glad you started! (although to be honest I was just planning on using you for any big events in my life anyway...)
I, for one, really appreciate your indignation on the subject, as it has always been something that irked me as well! We didn't feel like we had the money to spend on professional photographer for our wedding, after looking into prices, and that was something I really wanted; but after hearing about another friends (similar) wedding photo story, I was glad that we were able to go a different route, even if most of the pictures are not done by a professional. I also really appreciated what you said about not being embarrassed to be the picture taker; I find myself constantly in the position of being the one with the camera, and wanting to take pictures but not getting to because I am afraid of bugging people, or else because I actually get made fun of... so I am more than willing to make a stand with you on that one!! I also would like to be better at it, but until then I'll just keep snapping away...
Sorry, the length of this comment got way out of hand...
Very well said. Funny, but I have just gone through an photography experience just as you have described :) I feel very frustrated that I am unable to make a digital scrapbook page of my daughter's wedding because NO pictures are available. Oh! I took pictures, but sadly my hard drive crashed and I had stupidly NOT backed them up because I was at Primary Children's Hospital with my son who was on life support. I did purchase a picture for my wall from the photographer, but that is all I have.
Thank you for taking a stand. I hope you continue to develop your talents and become a professional photographer someday.
Steph, I TOTALLY agree with you! There are options other than professional photographers. I know that our ward alone has several very good photographers that take pictures for a very reasonable price and give their clients the disk of all the shots. I know that I did that when I was trying to make additional cash as a photographer. I loved being a part of people's family for their special events and I wouldn't dream of not giving them every memory I had captured. I got a lot of referrals and repeat business that way. Unfortunately, now I have a "real" job. I miss photography.
Post a Comment